12 Comments
User's avatar
Kate E. Deeming's avatar

The suicide myth has been knocked down time and time again. This is not only heresy it also is scientifically vacuous. Who is advising these men???? This upsets me to no end.

Expand full comment
Rob De Paoli's avatar

Horrified to learn that Catholic hospitals are conducting these surgeries. The rot of apostasy is spreading rapidly. It is only a matter of time before Francis concedes to it. My advice to Catholics and anyone in any denomination that supports this evil is this: “Come out of her, my people,’ so that you will not share in her sins, so that you will not receive any of her plagues..." [Revelation 18:4 NIV]

Expand full comment
Cheri's avatar

Has any effort been made to help gender confused persons to reaffirm their assigned birth gender? Something triggered this even if it was from childhood. Did mom or dad put pressure on the child into believing that he oe she disappointed them because of their sex, dress them, etc. Did a sibling of the opposite sex get way more attention? If you can block puberty, why can't you do the opposite? When someone is sick, you don't give them treatments to make them more sick. This life and our feelings are temporary. Our eternal life is what matters.

Expand full comment
Ger Ahrens's avatar

He's obviously jockeying for the pole position in the progressive lane of the papabile sweepstakes. No idea if this is right or wrong scientifically or sociologically, but one thing is certain, this has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with Christ, the Gospels, or God. I can read any medical journal if I want to, but as Holy Week approaches I would so love to hear these Vatican perverts and criminals say one sincere word about faith or even utter the name of Christ without using it to advance some political or sociological agenda.

Expand full comment
Michael Koopman's avatar

Burning at the stake is not good enough for such heresy.

I might be inclined to see this a little differently if there was any sound medical evidence that a reduction in suicide rates might be possible. There isn’t and none will be forthcoming. As Pope Francis has repeatedly stated, this ideology is of the devil.

So the only excuse Prince Soyboy of the church has is some inclusion in the corrupt pharmaceutical monies that the doctors are extorting from the victims who are mutilated by the quack medicine procedures. You know, the kind of deal that Judas cut for padding the retirement accounts of the disciples.

Expand full comment
Aamikee's avatar

Doctors now they are…

Expand full comment
Joseph Mulvey's avatar

Evil and devoid of reason and mercy. I pray this man is just mentally ill and not also oppressed by the fallen ones. No actual addressing the mental illness these people suffer and their pain.

Expand full comment
Nelson Barros's avatar

The Church receives the person, but never the sin — this is a fundamental principle of Catholic doctrine, upheld from the Church Fathers to the contemporary Popes.

Christ Himself gave the example: when He forgave the woman caught in adultery, He said, “Go, and sin no more” (John 8:11). In other words, love does not cancel out truth — it confirms it.

True charity requires the Church to continue proclaiming what is in accordance with natural and divine law, without yielding to cultural or ideological pressures that seek to blur the distinction between good and evil. To welcome, therefore, means to accompany the person with mercy, but never to approve of what is morally wrong.

This is authentic Christian compassion: one that seeks to save, not one that abandons the person in sin under the pretense of false tolerance.

Expand full comment
Jared's avatar

The headline here is just a bald-faced lie.

Expand full comment
D. Luscinius's avatar

If there’s one author I could downvote on this platform, it’s this guy. Seriously, just makes up garbage.

Someday we will all give a reckoning for our each word and what it wreaked in every soul. May God have mercy on us all.

Expand full comment
Ugochukwu Paul Nwaeze's avatar

this is the second article I am seeing from you, and it's so wild. Can I ask if your information is accurate, so when I share it, I am sure it's authentic? I am a Sedevacantist, so I am not surprised anyhow.

Expand full comment
Bryce Mitchell's avatar

Where in the document does Cardinal Fernández say that genital mutilation is permitted in extreme cases? I noticed that none of the quotes you provided say that sex change is allowed in any case. I read an English translation of the document, and it agrees with Dignitas infinita in rejecting sex change ("The document invites us to recognize the consequences of this belief when it rejects gender ideology and sex change.")

The quote you dishonestly used to imply that this document supports a loophole only says that it does not want to be cruel and recognizes that there are people who suffer from acute dysphoria. Nowhere does it say that this person is an exception to the rejection of sex change ideology.

Expand full comment